Table of Contents

Heinz is known for producing rich and creamy condiments for your meals that bring out the other flavor, and their mayonnaise is no different. With its perfectly balanced tang and creamy texture, Heinz mayonnaise has become a staple in many households. And what if you could make it at home for less than a cent per serving? This copycat Heinz mayonnaise recipe allows you to do just that, using simple ingredients to achieve the classic flavor and texture that you love.

In this post, we’ll guide you through a complete recipe for making Heinz mayonnaise at home, including detailed instructions, expert tips, serving suggestions, and ingredient alternatives. Whether you’re using it as a spread, dip or as an ingredient in your favorite recipes, this homemade mayonnaise won’t disappoint.

Ingredients for Copycat Heinz Mayonnaise

For the Mayonnaise:

First, 2 large room temperature egg yolks to ensure that our emulsion is rich and creamy.
Dijon mustard – 1 tablespoon = adds a slight tang and a big depth of flavor
1 teaspoon raw (or rice) vinegar – for acidic and balance
1 tablespoon very good quality vegetable oil – for good reasons
add 1/2 teaspoon salt to enhance the total flavor
neutral oil (like canola or vegetable oil) — without which mayonnaise wouldn’t be mayonnaise
1 tablespoon lemon juice — or half lemon – brightness, flavor
Sugar 1/2 teaspoon – balances the acidity and makes up the flavor

Step-by-Step Recipe Instructions for Heinz Mayonnaise

1. Prepare Your Ingredients

Read on for a step-by-step video of how to make carrot cupcakes with cream cheese frosting and check that all your ingredients are. This helps the emulsion come together more easily, resulting in a smoother and creamier Heinz mayonnaise. Do not use boiling eggs in your mayonnaise as the egg yolk quality plays a big part in the taste and texture of your mayonnaise.

2. Mix together the Egg Yolks and the Mustard

In a medium sized bowl mix your egg yolks, Dijon mustard and salt until smooth. The most important role of this mixture is to be the base of the mayonnaise, and the mustard helps to stabilize the emulsión. She whisked for about 1 minute until it was creamy and slightly thickened.

3. Slowly Add the Oil

Whisking it while you add the oil slowly, add a few drops at a time at first—just a few drops at first. Also important is that the emulsion is being built slowly, minimising the chance of it breaking down. After the mixture thickens and turns lighter in color, put the oil into the mixture at a very thin stream. Then, pour, and whisk constantly, to ensure the oil is fully incorporated.

4. Add Vinegar and Lemon Juice

Once you’ve added about half the oil, whisk in the white vinegar and lemon juice. It will thicken the mixture slightly, but also will help keep the stability of the emulsion. Whisk continuously while you add the remainder of the oil slowly in a stream.

5. Adjust Seasoning

After all the oil has been added, taste your Heinz mayonnaise and adjust the seasoning. If salt is needed, add some more of that and stir your sugar in for a twist of sweetness. If you like tangier taste add another teaspoon of lemon juice or vinegar. Mix the mayonnaise until it’s blended smoothly.

6. Store the Mayonnaise

Place it into a clean glass jar or airtight container once its all done. You can keep it in fridge for 1 week. Homemade Heinz mayonnaise has a fresh, rich flavor that will complement sandwiches, salads, and so much more.

Expert Tips for the Perfect Heinz Mayonnaise

1. Use Room Temperature Ingredients

All of the ingredients used to make the emulsion come at room temperature and since all the ingredients remain at room temperature, it is easy for the emulsion to come together smoothly. So cold the ingredients are, mayonnaise breaks, and it comes together as a mixture instead of cream.

2. Add The Oil Slowly

When making mayonnaise you want to add the oil very slowly — particularly in the beginning. If you put the oil in too quick, it won’t emulsify and you might have it separate. With just a handful of drops of the oil first, add the oil by a stream as the mixture begins to thicken.

3. Whisk Vigorously

The texture of true, homemade mayonnaise is worthy of the elbow grease it demands, and making mayonnaise by hand isn’t difficult. Make sure you use a sturdy whisk and whisk vigorously so you know that the egg yolks are really incorporated into the oil. You can also use a blender or ordinary immersion blender if you like something quicker.

4. Adjust the Acidity to Taste

One of the benefits of making your own Heinz mayonnaise is that you can adjust the tanginess to your preference. If you prefer a more acidic flavor add an extra teaspoon of lemon juice or vinegar.

What To Serve With Heinz Mayonnaise

Heinz mayonnaise

Classic Sandwich Spread

Use your homemade Heinz mayonnaise as a spread for sandwiches and wraps. It goes great with deli meats, cheese, fresh vegetables or etc. Creamy enough to add moisture and richness to a classic turkey club, a veggie wrap — whatever your sandwich of choice.

Potato Salad

Make a delicious potato salad by combining boiled potatoes with your homemade Heinz mayonnaise, chopped celery, onions, and a touch of mustard. The strong, intense creaminess of the mayonnaise coats everyone’s mouths with a potato charm.

Coleslaw

Create a quick coleslaw by mixing shredded cabbage and carrots with Heinz mayonnaise, apple cider vinegar, and a little sugar. BBQ ribs, or fried chicken, or burgers. It’s the ideal dish to side with.

French Fries and Vegetables dip

Elevate your French fry game by serving them with a side of Heinz mayonnaise. Even throw in a smidge of garlic or sriracha if you are into that sort of thing. It’s incredibly useful as a dip for fresh vegetables like cucumber sticks, bell peppers, and carrots.

Ingredient Alternatives

1. Egg-Free Mayonnaise

For those who are vegan or allergic to eggs, you can make an egg-free version of Heinz mayonnaise using aquafaba (the liquid from a can of chickpeas). If craving some creamy emulsion, use 3 tablespoons of aquafaba instead of the egg yolks, following the same steps.

2. Oil Alternatives

If you want a different flavor or one that is healthier, use avocado oil or maybe olive oil instead of canola or vegetable oil. Mayonnaise with avocado oil taste lighter, fresher, and olive oil will make a richer, more robust taste. Simply make sure you use a mild olive oil so that you don’t overpower the taste.

3. Flavored Mayonnaise Varieties

You can easily customize your Heinz mayonnaise with different flavors. Want some garlic aioli? Mix in some roasted garlic. A herbed mayo is mix in with some chopped fresh herbs (dill or parsley). How about a smoky, spicy twist? Add some smoked paprika.

4. Dijon Mustard Substitution

But if you don’t have Dijon mustard on hand, you can substitute regular yellow mustard or even a little toasted whole-grain mustard. Each will bring a slightly different flavor profile to your homemade Heinz mayonnaise.

Why This is a better recipe than any other

This copycat Heinz mayonnaise recipe stands out because it replicates the smooth, creamy texture and balanced flavor that make Heinz a favorite brand, but it’s made with fresh, simple ingredients. This homemade mayonnaise is healthier compared to store bought mayonnaise since you can control each ingredient’s freshness, leaving no preservatives and added sugar.

You can also adjust the recipe to your liking, being a bit more sweeter or tangy, or even more savory, than the one you would get from your store. The mayonnaise is versatile enough to be used in any recipe that requires a creamy, tangy condiment on sandwiches and dips, salad dressings, etc.

Why This Recipe is Perfect for Any Occasion

This Heinz mayonnaise recipe is perfect for any occasion, from everyday meals to special gatherings. This recipe makes a perfect match to your dishes whether you’re having a backyard BBQ, stuffing some family picnic goodies in a bag, or putting together a quick sandwich.

And because it’s made with just pantry staples, you can make it anytime (no trip to the store required). Another perk is that it’s a great if you’re looking to impress friends and family with homemade condiments that surpass the taste of slapping it in the cabinet from the store.

This recipe is also easily doubled or halved, perfect for large parties or for smaller smaller meals. It is customizable to suit any menu and is a fixture in your recipe library.

More Ways to Enjoy the Recipe

Homemade Ranch Dressing

Turn your Heinz mayonnaise into a creamy ranch dressing by mixing it with buttermilk, garlic powder, onion powder, dried dill, and a squeeze of lemon juice. This is great to drizzle over salads or a dip for veggies.

Spicy Mayo for Sushi Rolls

For a delicious sushi-inspired dip, mix your Heinz mayonnaise with sriracha or hot sauce. It’s a great addition to homemade sushi rolls or poke bowls for that combination of creamy and spicy heat.

Creamy Pasta Salad

Make a creamy pasta salad by combining cooked pasta with peas, diced bell peppers, red onion, and Heinz mayonnaise. A summery classic side dish that’s great for summer barbies or a light lunch.

Why The Recipe Stands Out

This copycat Heinz mayonnaise recipe stands out because it delivers the same creamy, tangy flavor that fans of Heinz know and love, but with the freshness and customization of homemade. Unlike most homemade mayonnaise recipes, this one is simple to make and uses ingredients that you may already have on hand. If you love the taste of mayonnaise but hate the preservatives and additives that can be found in store bought alternatives, it’s the perfect recipe for you!

The other advantage is that you are able to customize the flavor, whether you prefer a lighter, citrus flavor, or a richer, butter flavor you adjust the ingredients to suit. That’s why this is a good versatile recipe, with which you can tweak and use it again and again.

See Also: Copycat Kodiak Jack Pancakes Recipe

Nutritional Insights and Health Considerations

Each tablespoon of Heinz mayonnaise contains about 90 calories and 10g of fat, making it a rich and indulgent condiment. It’s the oil, and the majority of the calories, that makes mayonnaise so good: creamy. If you’re trying to cut down on the calorie content, use less oil or cut down with a lighter oil, like yogurt.

If you’re worried about raw eggs, you can use pasteurized egg yolks, or vegan with aquafaba. But with these alternatives you won’t have to worry about homemade mayonnaise going bad.

In conclusion, this copycat Heinz mayonnaise recipe is a great way to bring the rich, creamy flavor of your favorite brand into your home kitchen. It’s customizable, versatile, and easy to make, making it a condiment lover’s must have. Have it as a spread, dip or a flavor enhancer in your favorite recipes – this will tempt you to linger over it and realize how great homemade can taste.